Why are religious people so weird?

The Church as “Hospital”.
It is a question I’ve asked myself before - or once did so - and a question I’m frequently asked by others. Religion does seem to attract the misfits of society, perhaps none more so than the Catholic church. Non-religious friends often tell me they wouldn’t be caught dead in church because everyone there is so weird. (People who think they are normal amuse me.)
Whenever I attended any big city downtown Catholic church, I’ve often seen a variety of characters as well. The Mass and sacraments, along with the devotional life of the Church offers solace to troubled souls. In the Catholic religious goods store I manage, we meet people of every condition; some seem to be lost souls looking for guidance. When an employee remarks about how strange some of the people appear to be, (not you reading this!) I have an explanation at hand.
I remind them of the parable of the wedding banquet, where the king gave a banquet for his son, only to have the invited guests refuse the invitation for whatever reason. The king was furious and commanded his servants to go out into the byroads and invite anyone they happened upon - the lame and crippled, the blind and beggars, the prostitutes and tax collectors. Because it was for these that Jesus had come, the lowly and afflicted, “to bring glad tidings to the poor, to proclaim liberty to captives, recovery of sight to the blind, and release to prisoners.” Isaiah 61. The church is a refuge for sinners, a hospital for the suffering.
I am fond of a quote from Edith Stein in her work, “Science of the Cross”; “Former pride disappears when a man no longer finds anything in himself that might cause him to look down on others.”
Sometimes I think the mentally challenged, mentally ill, the addicted alcoholic, or just anyone with something wrong with them, is sort of a mirror for those of us who think we are normal. They show us something of ourselves, or what we could be. Yet more deeply, they call to us to recognize that they are people just like ourselves, people who need love, understanding, acceptance and a sense of belonging.
My own experience.
Having said that, it seems to me that over the years I have attracted my share of people with emotional or mental problems. It is probably because my mother was bi-polar and both parents were alcoholics, which made for a rather insane childhood, albeit really kind of hilarious. Hence my view of life as one big sitcom.
While living in Boston I somehow attracted many friends with mental disorders. I guess it was due in part that I spent hours in churches with adoration, and was seen as a compassionate person or something. (Or they may have sensed something of my childhood experience that permitted my acceptance of bizarre behavior.) At first, I may have considered some of these people to be eccentric, without ever realizing they suffered from genuine mental illness.
One friend, Steven, worked for a homosexual priest who was later murdered in jail, the infamous Fr. Gagnon. Steven told me all about him and his activities, introducing me to the priest several times. He was not a pleasant fellow. I therefore concluded Steve’s constant complaining and preoccupation with revelations that foretold a corrupt Catholic clergy had been a result of the stress he encountered working for this priest.
One evening we were out for supper and Steve dramatically showed me his hands exclaiming, “I have the stigmata!” I laughed out loud, lifting up my hands and said - “So do I!” - convinced he was joking. He wasn’t. He said it was invisible. I summoned up all the mystical theology I knew to try and convince him he was mistaken. It didn’t work.
The next day at Mass I saw his friend Mark and told him what had happened. Mark explained Steve had probably stopped taking his meds, revealing that Steve was schizophrenic. Again, I laughed and thought Mark was kidding, saying, “He is not! How would you even know that?”
That was when Mark told me he and Steve met in an institution and they were both diagnosed schizophrenics, yet if they took their medication, they were fully functional. I thought I was in the Twilight Zone. After recovering my shock, I continued to hang out with these guys from time to time, learning a great deal more about mental illness. They were a lot of fun too. (Tell me if I’ve told this story before.)
Jesus said those who are well do not need a doctor, sick people do. That is why there are so many weird people in church - remember that when you see me there.
March 6th, 2007 at 12:27 am
Call me crazy…heh - no pun intended - but I think all the odd people like the Pentecostal or Evangelical churches. At least they do around here (northern Canada).
I do notice that the Catholic women are much thinner than their evangelical counterparts. But again, maybe that’s just a Canadian thing.
March 6th, 2007 at 11:18 am
What a beautiful piece. Yes, I think EVERYthing you wrote is true. Growing up in the 60’s our Parish saw many large families and many Down’s Syndrome children, Cerebral Palsied and retarded. Whenever I’m in one of the newer Churches with the new Mass I never see much in retarded children, etc. When Catholics used to keep their marriages open to children and they couldn’t pick and choose if they would bring a “handicapped” child into the world you saw even more of God’s favored. My most beautiful childhood memory was of a Father of 11 who, every Sunday, carried his Cerebral Palsied little girl (truly a Saint) into Mass while the other children pushed in her special wheel chair. There was always so much love emenating from that Father’s face.
GIFT OF THE
SIXTH SORROW
Have you received
Christ’s body, dead?
Like the sorrowful Mother
Who cradled His head?
Christ’s body, dead,
Is the gift of a child
Deformed or sickly,
Did you feel beguiled?
Christ’s body, dead,
Is the gift of disease,
Physical, mental,
Can’t do as you please?
That’s because Christ
Wants to be close,
To you who accepts
The sixth sorrow’s dose.
He chose you of hope
To cradle His head,
For you know what’s life
And what really is dead.
Climb Golgotha hill,
You can handle,
So others can see,
Your light, like a candle,
That Christ is with you,
Before and behind,
And they’ll follow your path
To the tomb, quite resigned.
Where quietly, gently,
All suffering will rest
And your head will be cradled
At our Lady’s breast.
Oh sons of sorrow,
The gift? Your breath,
You’ll breathe at your birth
Due to Christ’s body’s death.
March 6th, 2007 at 1:52 pm
A very wise reflection. This is something my husband and I talk about all the time, why the Church attracts so many bizarre people (ourselves included.) Our Church is indeed a hospital, for the sick,for the wounded, for poor sinners.
March 6th, 2007 at 4:18 pm
Yes, this is a very good piece.
I recently jotted down some notes along a similar theme: Jesus is radically inclusive, and does not care who is “in” or who is “out”. The Church must stand for inclusion and radically against exclusion. Let’s remember that there are not many Catholics who have ever practiced or perfected every single facet of what being a good Catholic means. We all stuggle in our journey. And faith demands that we accept that God loves even the man or woman with whom we most strongly disagree with an unimaginable and infinite love.
March 6th, 2007 at 7:18 pm
Very interesting points. It does rather explain certain segments of the blogosphere. But, on the other hand, having known plenty of weird evangelicals, dingbat neo-pagans, disturbed agnostics, and downright unmentionable atheists, I’d have only one thing to say to the lot of them. “Dear Pot: Yes, I’m black. Signed: Kettle.”
March 7th, 2007 at 6:13 am
My youngest brother unfortunately now is a Christmas-Easter Catholic. My responsibility on those days is to tell him what time we need to go to Church.
Once we were late going to the baroque parish in Frogtown and we ended up going to the noon Mass. Wanting to give all advantages to his two children, he insisted we sit up with the Pharisees in the first row, with a good view of everything.
As all filed up for Communion, even I noticed how “different” the congregation was from the cultivated 10:00 crowd.
He laughingly commented on it as we were leaving and I agreed, further commenting “I saw a lot of Saints going to Communion today.”
March 7th, 2007 at 3:15 pm
“Dear Pot: Yes, I’m black. Signed: Kettle.”
That’s hilarious! And so true.