The Cafeteria is now open…
Warning: Some of the food may be tainted…
And the proprietor may be too busy trying to reinvent himself to care. But hey, decide for yourself - his comment on the new-old Cafeteria here: “Thankfully, my blog isn’t rated on the site you cite 
I consider my blog a personal rather than a Catholic blog with claim to orthodoxy ™. Admittedly, ex post, the blog title was a bad idea. It was meant as a bon mot re: Ratzinger. Apparently, on the internet the accusation of ‘Cafeteria Catholic’ is ubiquitous. In my defense, I was a pup when I started. I hadn’t even known how far out some people are, Frequently, they have a lot in common, regardless of whether they’d be viewed as ‘left’ or ‘right’. Dislike for democracy and individual rights, for example.” - Vox Nova
His latest post here seems to confirm my earlier observations here.
I have to believe he really would like to change the name of his blog, but as he commented to me once: “My blog’s really a personal opinion blog on many topics, not a ‘Catholic blog’ per se. With 2+ million visitors, it’s more popular than ever.” And what assurance does he have all of those people would follow him to a new site? Especially since it was the uber-Catholics who made him so popular (and contributed to his support) in the first place?